Buyer's Guide for Beer Lovers

Porters and Stouts

Always Bet on Black

Imperial Stout

Imperial stout is an extra strong version of stout, which was originally brewed by the British to withstand the rigors of export to Russia and the Baltic states. This style is dense, opaque black and strong in alcohol (6-7 percent), with a note of sweetness. Burnt cocoa and dried fruit flavors are typical. Russian Imperial stouts originate from recipes that British brewers tailored to the tastes of the Imperial Russian court. Imperial stout was almost extinct until recreated by the British brewer Samuel Smith in the early 1980s. The style has now been embraced by U.S. craft brewers as a winter specialty.

Interpreting the 100-point Scale

Consumers can translate the point score to the following quality bands:

Point Range Quality Band
96-100 points Platinum
90-95 points Gold
85-90 points Silver
80-84 points Bronze
Less than 80 Not Recommended
Legend
  • = Brewpub
  • ABV = Alcohol by volume
  • Date denotes the date on which the beer was tasted

97 Bourbon County Brand Stout, Goose Island Brewing Co. (IL) 2008. 13% ABV (1/09)
Opaque brown-black color with a saffron tint and lacy reddish brown color. Intense aromas of vanilla bean, spice, toffee and caramelized roasted nuts follow through on a rich, chewy entry to a dry-yet-fruity full body with delicious toasted raisin bread and dried cherry notes. Finishes with a long, complex, evolving toasted oak fade. A powerful and decadent imperial wood-aged stout.

94 The Abyss, Deschutes Brewery (OR). 11% ABV (1/09)
Inky black-brown color with a copper brown mousse. Melted baker’s chocolate, crème brulée, coffee gelato, roasted pecan and licorice aromas follow through on a satiny smooth entry to a low carbonation, dry-yet-fruity medium-full body with a great plush texture and beautifully integrated flavors. Finishes with a touch of caramelized golden raisins, espresso bean and chocolate-covered orange peel. A gentle giant of a stout.

94 Ryan Sullivan’s Imperial Stout, Moylan’s Brewing Co. (CA). 10% ABV (1/09)
Blackish brown color with a reddish tint and a fine tan mousse. Aromas of Bananas Foster, chocolate soufflé and honeyed raisin bread toast follows through on a silky, smooth entry to a dryish medium-to-full body with lingering charred nut, brown sugar and dried fruit notes. Finishes with chocolate-covered espresso bean, white peppercorn and bitter lemon peel fade. A broad shouldered and lively stout that will shine with grilled meats.

94 Old Rasputin Russian Imperial Stout, North Coast Brewing Co. (CA). 9.9% ABV (12/07)
Brown-black color with a light brown head. Toffee and citrusy, piney hops aromas and flavors with a rich, honeyed, medium full body with great, creamy frothiness. Rich lemon marmalade, celery salt, praline and resiny hops on the finish. A wild and woolly, broad shouldered, richly hopped West coast interpretation of the style that really works.

94 Imperial Stout, Rogue Ales (OR) 2006. 11% ABV (1/09)
Muddy black brown color with a taupe head. Toffee, molasses and black peppercorn aromas have a mossy clay edge and follow through on a rich, chewy entry to a dry-yet-fruity full body with great smoothness, depth and balanced. Finishes with a long, charred nut, bitter chocolate and mossy river stone fade with great astringency.

94 Imperial Chocolate Stout, Rogue Ales (OR). 9.5% ABV (1/09)
Muddy black-brown color with a medium brown head. Aromas of cashew brittle, melted toffee, vanilla custard and crayon follow through on a rich, supple entry to a fruity yet dry full body with fruit cake and delicate spice notes. Finishes with a rich artisanal (Venezuelan?) chocolate fade. A delicious post-prandial treat.

93 Sasquatch Stout, Harmon Brewing Co. (WA). 8.3% ABV (1/09)
Deep brown-black color with a reddish tint and a tan lacy head. Chocolate and roasted pecan aromas follow through on a soft, chewy entry to a dryish, medium-to-full body with toasted coconut and bitter citrus peel notes. Finishes with a long, toasted fruit-nut cake, coffee and molasses fade with balancing astringent hops. A very well-made and satisfying imperial stout.

93 Blackout Stout, Great Lakes Brewing Co. (OH). 9% ABV (1/07)
Dark brown-black color. Sweet fruit, dark caramelized nuts, raisin, aromas follow through to a frothy and crisp dry-yet-fruity medium body of raisin toast, chocolate-covered tangerines and dark caramel flavors with a fruity, tangy and mildly astringent fade. A very lively and fruity stout.

92 Ten Fidy Imperial Stout, Oskar Blues Brewery (CO). 9.5% ABV (1/09)
Muddy black color with a brown tint and frothy medium brown head. Melted chocolate, brown apple and delicate peppery spice aromas follow through on a rich, chewy entry to a dry medium-full body with dark roasted nuts and burnt sugar notes. Finishes with a long chocolate-covered dried peach, sautéed pepper and nut fade. A deliciously rich and chewy stout with great appeal.

92 Sick Duck Imperial Stout, Flyer’s Restaurant & Brewery (WA). 10% ABV (1/07)
Dark ruddy brown color. Dark caramel, sour cream, cocoa and grilled citrus aromas. A smooth and creamy entry leads to a dryish medium body of melted brown sugar, cocoa-dusted citrus and faint spice. Finishes with a tangy, fruity and lightly custardy fade with mild balanced astringency. Very interesting and reminiscent of fresh brownies. Yum.

90 The Midnight Oil Imperial Stout, Bastone Brewery (MI). 8.8% ABV (1/09)
Deep, dark brown color with a wispy tan head. Baker’s chocolate, faint dried cherry and subtle pork fat aromas follow through on a soft, creamy entry to a dryish medium-to-full body with a touch of cherry cider, mashed fig and Brazil nut. Finishes with a smooth, chewy oily fade. Nicely balanced and highly drinkable for an imperial stout.

90 Imperial Stout, Samuel Smith’s Old Brewery (England). 7% ABV (1/09)
Dark brown color with a frothy taupe head. Aromas of melted chocolate, white clay and spicy poached apple follow through on smooth, silky entry to a dryish medium body with roasted almond and roasted pepper notes. Finishes with bitter chocolate-covered sour cherry, dried apple and forest floor fade. A nicely balanced, easy drinking imperial stout.

88 Imperial Stout, North Peak Brewing Co. (MI). 8% ABV (1/09)
Opaque black-brown color with a frothy medium brown color. Chocolate-covered nut and delicate coffee aromas follow through on a satiny, smooth entry to dry medium-to-full body with bitter roasted espresso bean and kiwi notes. Finishes with chocolate-covered lemon rind and nectarine skin fade.

88 Imperial Stout, Bastone Brewery (MI). 9.25% ABV (1/08)
Opaque, dark brown color. Melted dark chocolate and nut bread toast aromas. A lively entry leads to a smooth, dry-yet-fruity medium-full body of creamy cocoa, honeyed nut toast, date and light cappuccino flavors. Finishes with pleasant satisfying super mild citrusy hop fade. A smooth, lighter-styled feminine imperial stout that hides the high alcohol extremely well; pair with grilled game or buffalo burgers.

83 Imperio, Cucapa (Mexico). 8.2% ABV (12/07)
Sweet caramel fudge, spice, hay and dishwater aromas with a sweet and musty character, tangy fruity, burnt marshmallow flavors. Medium full body with a bitter hop finish. Somewhat out of balance, but will be interesting with cheeses.

Add Your Comments